# What Makes a CHC Decision Flawed? | Nellie Supports

Source: https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/flawed-chc-decisions

Canonical: https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/flawed-chc-decisions

Written by: Ben Slater

Source review by: Kerry Slater

Source review recorded: 2026-07-20

# What makes an NHS Continuing Healthcare decision flawed

A CHC review request can address errors in the evidence, descriptors, primary health need reasoning or assessment process. Explain the specific concern and its effect on the decision. A disputed outcome does not, by itself, prove that the ICB applied the test incorrectly. This guide covers England.

A CHC review request can address errors in the evidence, descriptors, primary health need reasoning or assessment process. Explain the specific concern and its effect on the decision. A disputed outcome does not, by itself, prove that the ICB applied the test incorrectly. This guide covers England.

## Reasoning errors and procedural failures

The two are worth separating. A reasoning error means the test was applied wrongly, for example by disregarding well-managed needs or by treating a diagnosis as decisive. A procedural failure means the process was not followed, for example an improperly constituted team or a decision issued without reasons. Both are grounds for challenge, they call for different responses, and raising them separately is more effective than merging them.

## Disregarding well-managed needs

Check whether ongoing support was discounted because it manages needs successfully. Describe the care, frequency, skill and risks using the relevant descriptors. The DST does not require every condition to be scored as though medication or routine care were absent. A lasting reduction in active management may legitimately affect the assessment.

## Attributing needs by setting or provider

A need does not become a social care need because it is met in a care home, because a care assistant rather than a nurse delivers it, or because the local authority has been funding it. The Framework excludes setting, provider and funding source as decision factors. Wording in a decision letter that relies on any of them is a clear and identifiable defect.

## Deciding on diagnosis

No condition qualifies automatically and none is excluded. A decision that turns on the condition rather than on assessed needs has not applied the primary health need test. Phrases suggesting that a particular condition is a social care condition, or that dementia is not a health need, indicate this error directly.

## Missing characteristics analysis

Domain levels are evidence, not the decision. The assessment must analyse the needs through nature, intensity, complexity and unpredictability, and explain how that analysis supports the conclusion. A recommendation that moves straight from a set of levels to an outcome has missed a required step, and that gap is one of the more straightforward defects to identify.

## Levels not supported by the narrative

Read each level alongside its descriptor and the recorded narrative. If they appear inconsistent, identify the passage and ask how the descriptor was applied. Do not assume that either the level or the narrative is necessarily correct: relevant records and professional reasoning may be needed to resolve the difference.

## Departing from the recommendation

Where the Integrated Care Board has not accepted the multidisciplinary team recommendation, the Framework expects that to be exceptional and reasoned. A departure without identified defects in the assessment, or one that appears to substitute the Board's view for a properly reasoned professional judgement, is a strong procedural point.

## Gaps, blanks and absent voices

Blank or thinly evidenced domains, no contribution from anyone who knows the person day to day, no record of the family's account, and no consideration of night time or fluctuating needs are all defects. A blank domain is a gap in the assessment rather than a finding of no need, and it should be described that way.

## Key takeaway

Name the issue, explain why it matters and reference the evidence. Possible issues include omitted needs, incorrect descriptors, insufficient characteristics analysis, diagnosis-based reasoning or an unexplained departure from the MDT recommendation. Consider the impact on the overall decision as well as individual levels.

## Frequently asked questions

### Is disagreeing with a domain level enough?

On its own, rarely. Name the domain, quote the descriptor you say applies and provide dated evidence supporting it. A disagreement anchored to the tool's own wording is far stronger than an assertion that the level is too low.

### What should we check about managed needs?

One issue is whether needs were discounted because support manages them successfully. That concern must be checked against the actual care, evidence and DST descriptors. It is not necessary or appropriate to score every condition as though routine treatment had been withdrawn.

### Does a procedural failure win an appeal on its own?

Not usually on eligibility, but it can require the decision to be retaken properly. Raise procedural and reasoning points separately, since each calls for a different response from the reviewer.

### How do I show levels do not match the narrative?

Quote the narrative recorded in the Decision Support Tool alongside the level given, and set the descriptor next to both. Using the Board's own document to show the inconsistency is more persuasive than external evidence alone.

### What if the decision letter gives no reasons?

Request them in writing, along with the completed Decision Support Tool and the multidisciplinary team recommendation. A decision issued without reasons is itself a procedural point worth recording.

## Putting this into practice

Keep evidence and process concerns under clear headings. Explain what should be reconsidered and request the reasons, completed DST and MDT recommendation needed to understand the decision.

## Related NHS Continuing Healthcare pages

The links below explain related stages, funding arrangements and sources of support. Use the guidance that matches the decision or care issue you are dealing with.

[NHS Continuing Healthcare Support](https://www.nelliesupports.com/services/continuing-healthcare)

[How to appeal a CHC decision](https://www.nelliesupports.com/education-pages/challenging-a-chc-decision)

[The well-managed need principle](https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/well-managed-need-chc)

[The MDT recommendation and the final decision](https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/mdt-recommendation-versus-icb-decision)

[What evidence supports a CHC appeal](https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/evidence-for-a-chc-appeal)

## Sources and further reading

Department of Health and Social Care (2022) National Framework for NHS Continuing Healthcare and NHS-funded Nursing Care. Available at: [https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-framework-for-nhs-continuing-healthcare-and-nhs-funded-nursing-care](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-framework-for-nhs-continuing-healthcare-and-nhs-funded-nursing-care) Further guidance: DHSC, NHS continuing healthcare decision support tool guidance. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nhs-continuing-healthcare-decision-support-tool/nhs-continuing-healthcare-decision-support-tool-guidance

R (Grogan) v Bexley NHS Care Trust and others [2006] EWHC 44 (Admin).

Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman. Making a complaint about the NHS in England. Available at: [https://www.ombudsman.org.uk](https://www.ombudsman.org.uk/) The organisation has been called the Public Service Ombudsman since 1 October 2026; its NHS complaints role is unchanged.

R v North and East Devon Health Authority, ex parte Coughlan [2000] 2 WLR 622.

Written by Ben Slater, Registered Social Worker, Founder and Managing Director of Nellie Supports

Reviewed by Kerry Slater, Director of Operations

Last reviewed: 2026-07-20

## Author and Publication

Author: Ben Slater, Registered Social Worker, Founder and Managing Director of Nellie SupportsReviewed by: Kerry Slater, Director of OperationsLast reviewed: 20 July 2026

## Citation

1. Department of Health and Social Care (2022) National Framework for NHS Continuing Healthcare and NHS-funded Nursing Care. Available at: [https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-framework-for-nhs-continuing-healthcare-and-nhs-funded-nursing-care](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-framework-for-nhs-continuing-healthcare-and-nhs-funded-nursing-care)2. R (Grogan) v Bexley NHS Care Trust and others [2006] EWHC 44 (Admin).3. Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman. Making a complaint about the NHS in England. Available at: [https://www.ombudsman.org.uk](https://www.ombudsman.org.uk/)4. R v North and East Devon Health Authority, ex parte Coughlan [2000] 2 WLR 622. The organisation has been called the Public Service Ombudsman since 1 October 2026; its NHS complaints role is unchanged. Further guidance: DHSC, NHS continuing healthcare decision support tool guidance. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nhs-continuing-healthcare-decision-support-tool/nhs-continuing-healthcare-decision-support-tool-guidance

## Copyright

Copyright © 2026 Nellie Supports Ltd. All rights reserved.

This article is made available for general information, education and professional reference. It may be downloaded, printed and shared for non-commercial purposes, provided that it is reproduced in full, is not altered in any way, and is properly cited as the work of Nellie Supports Ltd. This material must not be edited, adapted, sold, republished, incorporated into commercial products, or used for commercial training, assessment, report-writing or advisory services without prior written permission from Nellie Supports Ltd.

This article does not constitute legal advice, clinical advice or a substitute for a decision-specific professional assessment. Where legislation, government guidance, court forms or external professional materials are referred to, those materials remain subject to their own copyright, licensing and re-use terms.

## Abstract

This guide identifies the errors that make an NHS Continuing Healthcare decision open to challenge. It distinguishes reasoning errors from procedural failures, covers the most common defects including disregard of well-managed needs, attribution by setting, missing characteristics analysis, unevidenced domain levels and departure from the multidisciplinary team recommendation, and explains how to frame each in a review request.

## Whats on this page

- [Overview](https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/flawed-chc-decisions)

- [Related Pages](https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/flawed-chc-decisions)

## Related NHS Continuing Healthcare pages

### How to appeal a CHC decision

### The well-managed need principle

### The MDT recommendation and the final decision

### What evidence supports a CHC appeal

## Using this guidance

This guide explains NHS Continuing Healthcare in England. You can take part in assessments and challenge an eligibility decision without buying a private report. Ask your ICB for its process, the relevant records and information about free advice or advocacy. Nellie Supports contact: [0333 987 5118](tel:03339875118).

## Primary sources and official guidance

[Official NHS Continuing Healthcare Decision Support Tool](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nhs-continuing-healthcare-decision-support-tool)

## Related information

- [NHS Continuing Healthcare Support](https://www.nelliesupports.com/services/continuing-healthcare)

---

Nellie Supports Ltd · 0333 987 5118 · nellie@nelliesupports.com

Office 11 and 12, Unit 20, Springfield Business Park, Grantham, NG31 7FZ
