# The Grogan Judgment Explained | Nellie Supports

Source: https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/grogan-judgment-chc

Canonical: https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/grogan-judgment-chc

Written by: Ben Slater

Source review by: Kerry Slater

Source review recorded: 2026-07-20

# The Grogan judgment and lawful CHC decision-making

If Coughlan decided where the boundary sits, Grogan decided that decision makers must actually apply it properly. It is the authority to reach for when a decision reaches a conclusion without showing its reasoning. This guide covers England.

If Coughlan decided where the boundary sits, Grogan decided that decision makers must actually apply it properly. It is the authority to reach for when a decision reaches a conclusion without showing its reasoning. This guide covers England.

## The facts

Maureen Grogan was severely disabled with multiple sclerosis and living in a nursing home. She had been assessed as not eligible for fully funded NHS continuing care and was receiving a nursing care contribution. She challenged the decision, arguing that the criteria applied and the way the assessment had been conducted were unlawful.

## What the court found

The court held that the criteria being applied were flawed and that the decision maker had failed to apply a proper test of primary health need consistent with Coughlan. The assessment had not properly identified whether her needs went beyond what a local authority could lawfully provide, and the decision was accordingly quashed.

## The principle it established

Grogan is a decision about process and reasoning rather than about where the boundary lies. It establishes that a decision maker must apply a lawful and properly articulated test, must engage with the Coughlan boundary, and must be able to show how the conclusion follows from the assessed needs. A conclusion without visible reasoning is vulnerable.

## Why it matters in practice

Grogan concerned unlawful eligibility criteria used before the national system now in place. Today, use the National Framework and DST guidance to identify missing or unsupported primary health need reasoning. The judgment provides background, but it does not mean every disputed domain level or brief decision letter is automatically unlawful.

## Substantive and procedural challenges

Grogan supports the procedural side of an appeal. A substantive ground says the levels or the conclusion were wrong on the evidence. A Grogan-type ground says the decision maker did not apply the test properly or did not show its reasoning. Running the two separately, under clear headings, produces better responses than merging them.

## Using it today

Use it briefly and specifically. Where the reasoning is missing, say that the decision does not show how the primary health need test was applied to the assessed needs, and ask for that reasoning. Referring to the requirement for a properly applied test is more effective than extended citation of the judgment itself.

## Key takeaway

Grogan requires decision makers to apply a lawful primary health need test and to show their reasoning. Where a decision moves from domain levels to a conclusion without any characteristics analysis, that is the point Grogan supports, and it belongs in the procedural section of a submission.

## Frequently asked questions

### What did Grogan decide?

That the criteria applied were flawed and that the decision maker had failed to apply a proper primary health need test consistent with Coughlan. The decision was quashed on that basis.

### How does Grogan differ from Coughlan?

Coughlan established where the boundary between NHS and local authority responsibility sits. Grogan established that decision makers must apply that boundary properly and show their reasoning.

### When should we rely on it?

Where a decision reaches a conclusion without visible reasoning, particularly where domain levels are recorded but there is no analysis of nature, intensity, complexity and unpredictability.

### Is this a substantive or procedural point?

It may concern the legal criteria as well as the decision-making process. In an NHS review, explain separately any evidence, descriptor and reasoning errors. If a legal challenge is contemplated, ask a solicitor how the judgment applies to the particular decision.

### Do we need to cite the case in full?

No. Refer briefly to the requirement for a properly applied and articulated primary health need test, and focus on what is missing from your own decision letter.

## Putting this into practice

Identify the missing reasoning in your own decision rather than citing a case name alone. Ask how the primary health need test was applied to the recorded needs.

## Related NHS Continuing Healthcare pages

The links below explain related stages, funding arrangements and sources of support. Use the guidance that matches the decision or care issue you are dealing with.

[NHS Continuing Healthcare Support](https://www.nelliesupports.com/services/continuing-healthcare)

[The Coughlan judgment](https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/coughlan-judgment-chc)

[What makes a CHC decision flawed](https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/flawed-chc-decisions)

[Procedural and substantive grounds of appeal](https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/chc-grounds-of-appeal)

[The four key characteristics explained](https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/four-key-characteristics-chc)

## Sources and further reading

Department of Health and Social Care (2022) National Framework for NHS Continuing Healthcare and NHS-funded Nursing Care. Available at: [https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-framework-for-nhs-continuing-healthcare-and-nhs-funded-nursing-care](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-framework-for-nhs-continuing-healthcare-and-nhs-funded-nursing-care)

R v North and East Devon Health Authority, ex parte Coughlan [2000] 2 WLR 622.

R (Grogan) v Bexley NHS Care Trust and others [2006] EWHC 44 (Admin).

Department of Health and Social Care (2022) NHS Continuing Healthcare Decision Support Tool.

Written by Ben Slater, Registered Social Worker, Founder and Managing Director of Nellie Supports

Reviewed by Kerry Slater, Director of Operations

Last reviewed: 2026-07-20

## Author and Publication

Author: Ben Slater, Registered Social Worker, Founder and Managing Director of Nellie SupportsReviewed by: Kerry Slater, Director of OperationsLast reviewed: 20 July 2026

## Citation

1. Department of Health and Social Care (2022) National Framework for NHS Continuing Healthcare and NHS-funded Nursing Care. Available at: [https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-framework-for-nhs-continuing-healthcare-and-nhs-funded-nursing-care](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-framework-for-nhs-continuing-healthcare-and-nhs-funded-nursing-care)2. R v North and East Devon Health Authority, ex parte Coughlan [2000] 2 WLR 622.3. R (Grogan) v Bexley NHS Care Trust and others [2006] EWHC 44 (Admin).4. Department of Health and Social Care (2022) NHS Continuing Healthcare Decision Support Tool.

## Copyright

Copyright © 2026 Nellie Supports Ltd. All rights reserved.

This article is made available for general information, education and professional reference. It may be downloaded, printed and shared for non-commercial purposes, provided that it is reproduced in full, is not altered in any way, and is properly cited as the work of Nellie Supports Ltd. This material must not be edited, adapted, sold, republished, incorporated into commercial products, or used for commercial training, assessment, report-writing or advisory services without prior written permission from Nellie Supports Ltd.

This article does not constitute legal advice, clinical advice or a substitute for a decision-specific professional assessment. Where legislation, government guidance, court forms or external professional materials are referred to, those materials remain subject to their own copyright, licensing and re-use terms.

## Abstract

This guide explains the High Court decision in R (Grogan) v Bexley NHS Care Trust and its significance for NHS Continuing Healthcare. It covers the facts, the court's findings about the criteria applied and the failure to apply a proper primary health need test, the difference between a substantive and a procedural challenge, and how the judgment is used in appeals today.

## Whats on this page

- [Overview](https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/grogan-judgment-chc)

- [Related Pages](https://www.nelliesupports.com/chc-guides/grogan-judgment-chc)

## Related NHS Continuing Healthcare pages

### The Coughlan judgment

### What makes a CHC decision flawed

### Procedural and substantive grounds of appeal

### The four key characteristics explained

## Using this guidance

This guide explains NHS Continuing Healthcare in England. You can take part in assessments and challenge an eligibility decision without buying a private report. Ask your ICB for its process, the relevant records and information about free advice or advocacy. Nellie Supports contact: [0333 987 5118](tel:03339875118).

## Primary sources and official guidance

[Official NHS Continuing Healthcare Decision Support Tool](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nhs-continuing-healthcare-decision-support-tool)

## Related information

- [NHS Continuing Healthcare Support](https://www.nelliesupports.com/services/continuing-healthcare)

---

Nellie Supports Ltd · 0333 987 5118 · nellie@nelliesupports.com

Office 11 and 12, Unit 20, Springfield Business Park, Grantham, NG31 7FZ
