Little Nellies · A guide for parents and young people
Refusal to issue an EHCP after assessment
After an EHC needs assessment, the council must issue a plan if it is necessary for special educational provision to be made through an EHC plan. A refusal to issue is therefore about whether a plan is necessary, not whether an assessment might be needed. Read all the advice and protect the separate appeal deadline.
The legal question after assessment
Section 37 of the Children and Families Act 2014 applies after the EHC needs assessment. Where it is necessary for special educational provision to be made through an EHC plan, the local authority must prepare and maintain one.
This is different from the 'may be necessary' assessment test. Explain why the identified special educational provision needs to be secured through a plan. A diagnosis alone does not determine that question, and the existence of some school support does not by itself settle it either.
Gather the complete assessment advice
Ask for the advice and information obtained during the assessment and read it alongside the refusal reasons. Identify what each report says about needs, required provision and how that provision can be delivered. Where a conclusion is vague or inconsistent with the evidence, identify the exact passage and ask what supports it.
Check whether relevant needs were explored and whether the assessment advice answers the important questions. Record missing or conflicting information. Do not assume that purchasing a new report is the only way to obtain clarification.
Organise the reasons a plan is necessary
- List the special educational needs identified by the evidence, including needs that remain disputed or insufficiently assessed.
- Set out the special educational provision required and which report or other evidence supports it.
- Explain what support has actually been delivered and what the records show about its effectiveness.
- Identify what remains unmet, how provision would be coordinated and why securing it through an EHC plan is necessary.
- Include the child or young person's views and representative family evidence, clearly separating observation from professional opinion.
Appeal preparation and deadlines
A refusal to issue can be appealed to the SEND Tribunal under section 51. You normally need mediation advice and a certificate, but do not have to attend mediation. The Tribunal must normally receive the appeal by the later of two months from the decision letter or one month from the certificate.
Use the current SEND35 route and instructions for a refusal to issue, rather than SEND35A for refusal to assess. Follow GOV.UK's current guidance, attach the required decision and certificate documents and explain why the plan is necessary. A request for reconsideration does not automatically stop the appeal clock.
Health and social care evidence may matter
Relevant health and social care information can explain needs and daily functioning, but each recommendation needs to be classified correctly. Under section 21(5), health or social care provision which educates or trains is treated as special educational provision. This does not mean every social care service belongs in Section F.
An eligible extended appeal can include non-binding health or social care recommendations alongside the education appeal. Get advice about the available scope in your particular appeal. Do not treat that route as a standalone appeal against every care or health decision.
Choose support for the gap in your case
You may need free advice, a focused evidence review, a professional clarification, an independent assessment or representation. A solicitor is not compulsory, but specialist legal advice may be useful for difficult legal issues or uncertainty about the correct remedy.
Our refusal appeal service has an agreed casework scope. Review the support options guide before committing. No service or report guarantees that a plan will be issued.
Your questions
Is refusal to issue the same as refusal to assess?
No. Refusal to issue follows an EHC needs assessment and concerns whether special educational provision through a plan is necessary. Refusal to assess concerns whether the child or young person has or may have SEN and whether special educational provision through an EHC plan may be necessary.
Does a professional recommendation mean the council must issue a plan?
The recommendation is relevant evidence, but the statutory question still needs to be addressed. Read the reasoning, the provision identified and why a plan is necessary.
Can I ask the council to reconsider and appeal?
You can discuss the decision, but informal discussions do not automatically extend the appeal deadline. Protect the deadline and get advice on the procedural next step.
Sources and scope
England only. General information, not individual legal advice. Official guidance and the sources below were checked for this update on 11 November 2026. The Tribunal controls procedure and decides each case. For advice about your own case, consult a suitably qualified legal adviser.
- Children and Families Act 2014, section 37
- Children and Families Act 2014, section 51
- GOV.UK: appeal an EHC plan decision
- IPSEA: extended appeals
Little Nellies is the SEND and EHCP service of Nellie Supports Ltd. We provide agreed advocacy, independent social work input and hearing representation, not a solicitors’ service. See services and scope.
