Little Nellies · A guide for parents and young people
Refusal to assess for an EHCP: your next steps
A refusal to assess is not a refusal to issue an EHCP after assessment. The council must apply the assessment-stage test: the child or young person has or may have SEN, and provision through an EHC plan may be necessary. Check the reasons against that test and protect your appeal deadline.
What the assessment-stage test says
Under section 36(8) of the Children and Families Act 2014, the local authority must secure an EHC needs assessment where the child or young person has or may have special educational needs and it may be necessary for special educational provision to be made through an EHC plan.
The word 'may' matters. At this stage the question is whether assessment is required, not whether you can already prove the final plan is necessary. A diagnosis is not an additional statutory requirement, and a blanket rule that the school must first spend £6,000 does not replace the statutory test. Read IPSEA's assessment guidance.
Read the refusal letter actively
- Record the decision date, stated reasons, appeal information and mediation-adviser details.
- Check whether the council considered the evidence you supplied and the legal test it applied.
- Separate a blanket policy statement from an explanation of this child or young person's needs and support.
- Check whether evidence of difficulties is being overlooked because support or family help is masking their impact.
- Identify what the council says is missing and whether that information should be gathered through assessment rather than treated as a reason to refuse it.
Evidence that may help
Use school or college SEN records, progress and support reviews, relevant health or social care information, parent observations and the child or young person's views. Explain the needs that may be present, the support already being provided and why assessment and provision through a plan may be necessary.
Be specific about what has been tried and what remains unclear or unmet. You do not automatically need a private assessment to appeal. Identify a genuine gap before buying another report. See the appeal evidence checklist.
Mediation, the deadline and SEND35A
You normally need to contact a mediation adviser and obtain a certificate before appealing this decision. You do not have to attend mediation. The Tribunal must normally receive the appeal by the later of two months from the council's decision letter or one month from the certificate.
The usual refusal-to-assess form is SEND35A. Use the current form and instructions linked from GOV.UK's appeal guidance. Include the required documents and explain the grounds clearly. Informal reconsideration or a complaint does not automatically extend the appeal deadline. If it has passed, seek prompt advice about a late appeal request.
Do you need a solicitor?
Not automatically. You may appeal yourself, seek free SENDIASS or IPSEA advice, or appoint a suitable representative. Ask for specialist legal advice if the proper route, the law or your authority to act is unclear. More paid input is not always a substitute for explaining the correct assessment-stage question.
Little Nellies offers refusal appeal support within an agreed scope. We check the decision, existing work and deadlines before confirming suitability and fees. We are not solicitors and do not guarantee assessment or a later EHCP.
What a successful assessment appeal does, and does not, decide
A successful refusal-to-assess appeal requires the assessment to take place. It does not automatically decide that an EHCP must be issued or name a school. If the authority later assesses but refuses to issue a plan, that is a different decision with a separate test and appeal route. Read the refusal-to-issue guide.
Your questions
Can the council refuse because there is no diagnosis?
A diagnosis is not an extra statutory condition. The question is whether the child or young person has or may have SEN and provision through a plan may be necessary.
Do I need the school's permission to appeal?
The parent's or eligible young person's appeal right does not depend on the school agreeing. Relevant school evidence can still help. Check who holds the right of appeal in your circumstances.
Will winning guarantee an EHCP?
No. It means an assessment must be carried out. The decision whether a plan is necessary follows that assessment and uses a different legal test.
Sources and scope
England only. General information, not individual legal advice. Official guidance and the sources below were checked for this update on 11 November 2026. The Tribunal controls procedure and decides each case. For advice about your own case, consult a suitably qualified legal adviser.
- Children and Families Act 2014, section 36
- IPSEA: requesting assessment
- GOV.UK: mediation before appeal
- GOV.UK: current appeal instructions
Little Nellies is the SEND and EHCP service of Nellie Supports Ltd. We provide agreed advocacy, independent social work input and hearing representation, not a solicitors’ service. See services and scope.
