top of page
  • Writer's pictureTeam Nellie

The Causative Nexus: Unraveling the Complexities of Mental Capacity in Light of the Mental Capacity


Mental capacity is a critical issue that demands careful attention, particularly in the context of social work and healthcare services. At Nellie Supports, we understand the complexities and challenges related to mental capacity evaluations, and the subsequent implications it can have on a person's life. This is even more pertinent in light of the Mental Capacity Amendment Bill 2019, which has reshaped the testing criteria and framework for determining mental capacity in the UK. In this blog, we explore the causative nexus that influences mental capacity and discuss its relevance in our practice.

Mental Capacity: Beyond a Single Definition

Mental capacity is not a one-dimensional construct; it is influenced by a myriad of factors. The cognitive, emotional, and social aspects of an individual's mental capacity interact in a complex manner. The ability to process information, make decisions, and solve problems is often interlinked with emotional intelligence, life experiences, and social support networks.

The Mental Capacity Amendment Bill 2019: What Changed?

The Mental Capacity Amendment Bill 2019 brought significant changes to how mental capacity is assessed in the UK. The new framework replaces the original two-stage test outlined in the Mental Capacity Act (MCA) and introduces new terms:

  1. Functional Test (Stage 1): This assesses an individual's ability to understand, retain, and weigh information to make a decision.

  2. Diagnostic Test (Stage 2): This involves diagnosing the presence of an impairment or disturbance that affects the mind or brain.

The revised test aims to provide a more nuanced and comprehensive approach to mental capacity evaluations, although it has been the subject of debate among healthcare professionals.

The Causative Nexus

Understanding mental capacity requires examining a web of causative factors that extend from genetics to environment:

  1. Genetics: Research indicates that cognitive abilities have a genetic component, although it's far from the only determinant.

  2. Environment: Educational opportunities, access to healthcare, and even diet can influence cognitive development and mental capacity.

  3. Lifestyle Factors: Stress, sleep, and exercise also play crucial roles in shaping an individual's mental capacity.

  4. Psychological Factors: Mental health conditions, including depression and anxiety, can impair cognitive function and decision-making abilities.

  5. Social and Cultural Factors: Family dynamics, social support networks, and cultural norms can significantly affect an individual's perception and decision-making abilities.

Implications for Nellie Supports

As an independent social work practice, understanding the causative nexus of mental capacity is paramount. We employ the revised framework provided by the Mental Capacity Amendment Bill 2019 to conduct more comprehensive assessments for our clients. By appreciating the complexity of factors that influence mental capacity, we can tailor our services to offer holistic, client-centred support.


The Mental Capacity Amendment Bill 2019 has made understanding the causative nexus of mental capacity more complex but also more nuanced. This complexity allows for more accurate and individualized assessments and plans for support. At Nellie Supports, we are committed to staying abreast of legislative changes and scientific advancements to offer the best possible service to our clients.

For more information or to consult with our specialists, please get in touch with us.

31 views0 comments


bottom of page