Independent expertise. Human understanding.0333 987 5118

GUIDES

Procedural and substantive grounds of CHC appeal

Appeals are stronger when the grounds are sorted into the right categories. A point about whether the conclusion was correct calls for a different response from a point about whether the process was followed. Mixing them tends to produce a reply that addresses neither properly.

On this page20 sections

Appeals are stronger when the grounds are sorted into the right categories. A point about whether the conclusion was correct calls for a different response from a point about whether the process was followed. Mixing them tends to produce a reply that addresses neither properly.

The two categories

Substantive grounds concern the outcome: the domain levels were wrong, the characteristics analysis was flawed, the primary health need test was misapplied. Procedural grounds concern how the decision was reached: the team was not properly constituted, the family's evidence was not recorded, the recommendation was departed from without reasons, no written decision was provided. Both are legitimate and they are best raised separately.

Substantive grounds in practice

Record the current need and the continuing care required to manage it. A well-managed need remains relevant, but DST guidance says not to assess every condition as though routine care or medication were absent. Each should be tied to specific domains and dated evidence rather than expressed as a general disagreement.

Procedural grounds in practice

The most common are an improperly constituted multidisciplinary team, no contribution from anyone who knows the person day to day, the family's account not recorded, the completed Decision Support Tool not provided, a decision issued without reasons, and the Integrated Care Board departing from the recommendation without identifying a defect in the assessment.

Why separating them matters

The remedies differ. A successful substantive ground points towards the decision being overturned. A successful procedural ground more often points towards the assessment being redone properly. Setting them out separately lets the reviewer address each on its own terms, and it avoids a response that answers the process point and treats the eligibility point as covered.

Structuring the submission

Two headed sections work well. Under substantive grounds, list each domain with the level recorded, the level contended for, the descriptor and the evidence. Under procedural grounds, list each failure with the date and what should have happened. Keep both short, and lead with the strongest point in each category rather than the chronological first.

Grounds that rarely succeed alone

Delay, poor communication or staff conduct do not by themselves establish a primary health need and may need the NHS complaints route. If a process failure prevented a fair and robust eligibility decision, explain that effect in the review request as well. Keep the requested remedies clear rather than excluding a relevant procedural concern automatically.

Keeping the record

Whichever grounds you rely on, keep a dated written record of what was submitted and how the Board responded. If the matter progresses to an Independent Review Panel, the panel will want to see what was argued at local resolution and whether it was engaged with. An unanswered ground is itself a point worth making.

Key takeaway

Sort your grounds into substantive and procedural, set them out under separate headings, tie each substantive point to a domain and dated evidence, and keep complaints about delay or conduct in the complaints process where they belong.

Frequently asked questions

Which type of ground is stronger?

Neither is inherently stronger. Substantive grounds point towards the decision being overturned, procedural grounds more often towards the assessment being redone. Running both gives the reviewer two routes to a remedy.

Is delay a ground of appeal?

Delay alone does not prove eligibility. Use the complaints route for the delay and any resulting service or financial harm. If it also affected evidence or the fairness of the eligibility decision, explain that specific effect in the review request; urgent or unresolved delay may need separate legal advice.

Can I add grounds later?

Check the stage’s instructions and deadline before assuming further material can be added. Ask promptly to supplement a local-resolution submission. NHS England independent review has specific limits on new evidence and its application process; send relevant points early and request help or an extension if needed.

Do I need to use legal language?

No. Plain description of what happened and what the evidence shows is more effective. What matters is that each ground is specific, dated and tied to something the reviewer can check.

What if a ground is not addressed?

Say so, in writing, and repeat the ground. An unanswered ground is a point in itself at the next stage, and the Independent Review Panel will look at whether local resolution engaged with what was argued.

A practical next step

Identify the decision and period challenged, then set out factual, reasoning and procedural concerns with the relevant evidence. Explain how each point could affect a fair eligibility decision. Confirm submission deadlines and the rules on further material at the stage you are using.

Related NHS Continuing Healthcare pages

These pages explain related stages of the NHS Continuing Healthcare process in England. The service page describes optional paid support.

NHS Continuing Healthcare Support

What makes a CHC decision flawed

What evidence supports a CHC appeal

Common reasons CHC appeals do not succeed

How to appeal a CHC decision

Sources and further reading

Department of Health and Social Care (2022) National Framework for NHS Continuing Healthcare and NHS-funded Nursing Care. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-framework-for-nhs-continuing-healthcare-and-nhs-funded-nursing-care

R (Grogan) v Bexley NHS Care Trust and others [2006] EWHC 44 (Admin).

Public Service Ombudsman (formerly the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman). Making a complaint about the NHS in England. Available at: https://www.ombudsman.org.uk

R v North and East Devon Health Authority, ex parte Coughlan [2000] 2 WLR 622.

Written by Ben Slater, Registered Social Worker, Founder and Managing Director of Nellie Supports

Reviewed by Kerry Slater, Director of Operations

Last reviewed: 2026-07-20

Author and Publication

Author: Ben Slater, Registered Social Worker, Founder and Managing Director of Nellie SupportsReviewed by: Kerry Slater, Director of OperationsLast reviewed: 20 July 2026

Citation

1. Department of Health and Social Care (2022) National Framework for NHS Continuing Healthcare and NHS-funded Nursing Care. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-framework-for-nhs-continuing-healthcare-and-nhs-funded-nursing-care2. R (Grogan) v Bexley NHS Care Trust and others [2006] EWHC 44 (Admin).3. Public Service Ombudsman (formerly the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman). Making a complaint about the NHS in England. Available at: https://www.ombudsman.org.uk4. R v North and East Devon Health Authority, ex parte Coughlan [2000] 2 WLR 622.

Copyright

Copyright © 2026 Nellie Supports Ltd. All rights reserved.

This article is made available for general information, education and professional reference. It may be downloaded, printed and shared for non-commercial purposes, provided that it is reproduced in full, is not altered in any way, and is properly cited as the work of Nellie Supports Ltd. This material must not be edited, adapted, sold, republished, incorporated into commercial products, or used for commercial training, assessment, report-writing or advisory services without prior written permission from Nellie Supports Ltd.

This article does not constitute legal advice, clinical advice or a substitute for a decision-specific professional assessment. Where legislation, government guidance, court forms or external professional materials are referred to, those materials remain subject to their own copyright, licensing and re-use terms.

Abstract

This guide explains the two categories of ground on which an NHS Continuing Healthcare decision can be challenged. It distinguishes substantive grounds, which concern whether the eligibility conclusion was right, from procedural grounds, which concern whether the decision was properly made, gives examples of each, and explains why separating them produces better responses at local resolution and panel stage.

What’s on this page

Related NHS Continuing Healthcare pages

What makes a CHC decision flawed

What evidence supports a CHC appeal

Common reasons CHC appeals do not succeed

How to appeal a CHC decision

Further help with the process

This guide covers NHS Continuing Healthcare in England. Ask the ICB's continuing healthcare team about the next stage and any local forms or deadlines. For an enquiry to Nellie Supports, call 0333 987 5118. You do not need to buy private support to request an NHS assessment or challenge a decision.

Primary sources and official guidance

Official NHS Continuing Healthcare Decision Support Tool

A GOOD PLACE TO START

You do not need all the answers.
Just a place to start.

Tell us what is happening and what you need help with. We will listen, explain the options and help you find the right starting point.