Independent expertise. Human understanding.0333 987 5118

Independent expert evidence · England and Wales

Litigation reports and expert assessments

Clear instructions. Evidence-led analysis.

Nellie Supports provides independent expert evidence on mental capacity, care needs, future care costs and life expectancy for legal proceedings and complex disputes. We work with solicitors, deputies, insurers and families across England and Wales, matching each instruction to the right professional and a clearly defined question.

Independent professional opinion. Scope, fees and deadlines agreed before instruction.

Three adults discussing paperwork around a table.
Service overview

Nellie Supports provides independent expert evidence on mental capacity, care needs, future care costs and life expectancy for legal proceedings and complex disputes.

We work with solicitors, deputies, insurers and families across England and Wales, matching each instruction to the right professional and a clearly defined question.

Clear instructions. Evidence-led analysis. Independent professional opinion.

Coverage: England & Wales

Scope and quotation: Case-specific

Expert opinion: Independent

Report deadlines: Agreed in writing

Expert evidence that answers the question in your case

Two women talking over mugs in a sitting room.

The right report depends on the issue before the court or the decision being considered. A capacity opinion, a projection of care costs and a review of an existing report answer different questions and may require different expertise.

We clarify the purpose, relevant date, evidence available and intended use before work begins. The report then explains the material considered, the method used and the reasoning behind the opinion, including gaps or limitations that affect the conclusion.

A retrospective capacity assessment considers a specified past decision using available records and corroborating material. Care needs reports address current and projected support requirements.

Life expectancy opinions require relevant expertise and a transparent method. Confirm the named expert, evidence and any specialist clinical input for the instruction.

What is an expert report?

An expert report is a reasoned professional opinion addressing a defined question within the author's expertise. It should make the evidence and reasoning clear enough for others to examine.

Explore our litigation and expert reporting services

Choose the report that answers the question in your case. Each service below links to its detailed scope.

Retrospective capacity

Evidence about capacity at an identified point in the past.

Explore this support

Care needs reports

Assessment of current and projected care requirements.

Explore this support

Life expectancy

Discuss the evidence and specialist input required.

Explore this support

Mental capacity

Find the appropriate decision-specific assessment route.

Explore this support

Independent evidence for legal proceedings

The report format and professional approach follow the instruction and the rules applicable to the proceedings.

The expert addresses questions within their own expertise.

Where CPR Part 35 applies, the duty to assist the court takes priority over the instructing party's interests.

Permission to rely on expert evidence is a matter for the court.

Define the question before choosing the report

A focused instruction helps the expert address the issue that matters.

The exact question the report must answer

Whether the opinion concerns the present or an identified historical date

The proceedings, relevant directions and intended use of the report

The records available, disputed evidence and known gaps

The required expertise, deliverables and deadline

Independence comes first

Where CPR Part 35 applies, the expert's duty to assist the court overrides their obligation to the party instructing or paying them. We explain what the evidence supports, including findings that may not favour the instructing party.

How to instruct an expert report

  1. Discuss the case

    Tell us the issue, who the report concerns, the stage of proceedings and any deadline. We identify the report or combination of services that may be appropriate.

  2. Agree scope and fees

    We confirm the questions, relevant dates, required records, professional expertise, deliverables and timescale in writing before the instruction proceeds.

  3. Assessment and evidence review

    The allocated professional reviews the relevant material and, where needed, meets the person with appropriate support for communication and participation.

  4. Analysis and report preparation

    The report separates evidence from opinion, explains the reasoning and identifies any limitations. Our internal review checks clarity, structure and evidential reasoning.

  5. Secure delivery and follow-up

    The report is delivered to the agreed recipient. Any further clarification, expert discussion, additional report or court attendance is scoped according to the needs of the case.

Supporting participation in the assessment

Where direct assessment is needed, arrangements should help the person engage with the relevant questions.

Communication needs

Tell us about language, sensory or communication needs so suitable support can be planned.

Timing and setting

We agree appropriate arrangements around the person's circumstances and the purpose of the assessment.

Clear professional boundaries

Support helps the person participate; the resulting opinion remains independent.

Evidence that strengthens the instruction

The material needed depends on the report. We confirm the relevant documents before work begins.

Instructions and directions

The questions, relevant dates, purpose of the report and any applicable court directions.

Records and previous reports

Relevant medical, care and assessment records, with a clear account of what is missing.

A case chronology

Key events and dates, including the decision or period under examination.

Alternative accounts

Relevant conflicting accounts or opinions so the expert can consider the evidence fairly.

What your expert report should make clear

The precise format follows the instruction and applicable procedural requirements.

The instruction, questions and relevant dates

The author's qualifications and scope of expertise

Records, information and sources considered

Assessment methods and support for participation

Findings and the distinction between fact and opinion

Reasoning, assumptions and alternative explanations

Conclusions, limitations and further evidence needed

Required declarations and supporting appendices

Fees reflect the work your case requires

A written quotation sets out the agreed scope. We do not apply one generic assessment fee to every expert report.

A single report or review

A focused instruction to answer a defined question, assess a particular decision or review existing evidence.

A coordinated evidence package

Several related questions may require complementary reports, such as care needs, costs, capacity and life expectancy.

Choose the evidence your case needs

Start with the question that must be answered, then select the type of instruction.

A current capacity assessment

A person's ability to make a defined decision now

A retrospective capacity opinion

Capacity at a particular date in the past

A critical review

The quality of an existing capacity report

Care needs and future costs

The person's support needs and likely care expenditure

Life expectancy evidence

The duration relevant to future planning or loss

A statutory will package

Coordinated evidence for an application

One case can need more than one kind of evidence

In a personal injury matter, a solicitor may need to understand both whether a person can conduct proceedings and what support they will require in the future.

A capacity assessment addresses the person's decision-making ability. A care needs and costings report addresses support and expenditure. Where duration is material, a separate life expectancy opinion may also be needed. Agreeing these questions early helps keep each report focused.

Illustrative scenario only; this is not a client case or a claimed outcome.

Information to send with an enquiry

A short, clear instruction helps us identify the right professional and avoid gaps.

The question and legal context

State what the report must address, the relevant date and the intended use. Include a letter of instruction or relevant directions where available.

The evidence available

Identify records, prior assessments, medical opinions and other material already held. Tell us about material that is missing or disputed.

The person and practical arrangements

Provide the person's location, communication needs and any arrangements necessary for an appropriate assessment.

Dates and deliverables

Tell us the required report date, any hearing or filing deadline, and whether further expert work may be needed.

Support for families and instructing professionals

The same commitment to clear, independent evidence applies whoever makes the enquiry.

For individuals and families

We explain which assessment may help, what information is needed and what the report can address. Where legal proceedings are involved, we can coordinate with your solicitor so the instruction is clear.

For legal professionals, deputies and insurers

We scope the evidential question, relevant records and deadline at the outset, allocate an appropriately qualified professional and provide a structured report with transparent reasoning.

Why instruct Nellie Supports?

Defined professional scope

The instruction is matched to the question and the expertise needed to answer it.

Evidence you can follow

Reports explain how the information considered leads to the professional opinion.

Independent conclusions

Opinions reflect the evidence and acknowledge uncertainty or gaps.

Coordinated communication

Scope, practical arrangements and deadlines are agreed through one practice.

Litigation and expert report FAQs

What should an instruction include?

Start with the question, intended use, relevant documents and deadline. Confirm any court requirements with your solicitor. Ask the team.

Are all reports completed by the same professional?

The appropriate expertise depends on the question. Confirm who will prepare and take responsibility for the life expectancy opinion and any additional specialist input. Ask the team.

Can you promise a court outcome?

No. An independent opinion follows the evidence and does not guarantee how a court will treat it. Ask the team.

What types of expert reports do you provide?

Our services include capacity to litigate assessments, Advanced and Enhanced mental capacity assessments, retrospective opinions, critical reviews, personal injury capacity assessments, future care and costings reports, life expectancy reports and statutory will evidence packages.

Are reports prepared for court use?

We confirm the intended use and required format at instruction. Where CPR Part 35 applies, the report is prepared to those requirements. Different proceedings may have different rules and directions; a report does not itself guarantee permission to rely on expert evidence.

Who can instruct Nellie Supports?

We receive enquiries from a range of people, including legal professionals, professional deputies, insurers, case managers and families. Where proceedings are underway, a clear instruction coordinated with the legal team helps define the questions and evidence required.

How do I choose between a new assessment and a critical review?

A new assessment gathers evidence about the person's decision-making. A critical review examines the quality of an existing report. We can discuss which task matches the question you need answered.

What does a retrospective capacity assessment consider?

It considers capacity at an identified date in the past using the material available from that period. The opinion must explain the quality of that evidence and any limits on the conclusion.

Does an enhanced assessment guarantee a particular finding?

No. An enhanced assessment allows more detailed enquiry where complexity warrants it. The conclusion remains independent and follows the evidence.

How much will the report cost?

The fee depends on the report type, complexity, records and work required. We confirm the quotation, VAT treatment, travel and any additional work in writing before instruction.

All travel is charged separately at £48 per hour including VAT (£40 excluding VAT). The travel cost and any additional work are confirmed in your written quotation before booking.

How long does a report take?

Timescales depend on the instruction, records, assessment arrangements and complexity. Tell us any deadline at the first enquiry so we can confirm what is achievable.

Can several reports be coordinated?

Yes. Some matters require complementary evidence, such as capacity, care costs and life expectancy. We agree the necessary components and responsibilities before work starts.

What happens after delivery?

Further clarification or additional expert work can be discussed with the instructing party. Any expert meetings, supplementary reports or attendance requirements should be identified and scoped.

Guidance and professional standards

Our professional standards

How professional governance and report quality are supported within the practice.

Meet the team

Learn about the people delivering our assessments and reports.

CPR Part 35

The official Civil Procedure Rules on experts and assessors.

Related Nellie Supports services

Mental capacity assessments

Explore the wider range of decision-specific capacity assessments.

Social care and care planning

Independent social care assessment and ongoing support.

NHS Continuing Healthcare support

Support with CHC assessment and review processes.

Types of expert evidence

Care needs and future costs

Evidence of the support a person needs and the costs of meeting those needs over time.

Life expectancy

Individualised life expectancy analysis for cases where future duration matters.

Capacity in legal proceedings

Assessment of the person's ability to make the decisions involved in their legal matter.

Disputed and historical capacity

Detailed assessment, historical analysis and scrutiny of existing capacity evidence.

Personal injury capacity

Decision-specific assessment following injury, where cognition or communication may affect decision-making.

Statutory will evidence

Coordinated assessment evidence for a Court of Protection statutory will application.

The applicable framework

Civil, family and Court of Protection proceedings have their own requirements. The instruction should identify the relevant rules and court directions.

Different questions need different evidence

Capacity, care costs and life expectancy are distinct issues. A report on one should not be treated as answering the others.

The expert's role

Evidence must be relevant to the issues the expert is instructed to address.

Nellie Supports provides independent assessment and expert evidence, not regulated legal advice. Your solicitor advises on legal strategy and the court determines the proceedings.

Tell us what your case needs to establish

Send us a brief outline of the case, the questions to be answered, the records available and any deadline. We will confirm the appropriate service, professional, scope, fee and timescale in writing.

How The Nellie Standard™ Applies to Litigation and Expert Reports

This service is delivered in accordance with The Nellie Standard™, Nellie Supports’ framework for evidence-led assessment, reporting and advocacy.

For Litigation and Expert Reports, The Nellie Standard™ means the report is approached as formal, evidence-led professional work that may be reviewed by solicitors, counsel, insurers, deputies, local authorities or the court. The report should not simply summarise background information; it should answer the instructed question with clear reasoning and identifiable evidence.

In this service, particular attention is given to the instructed issue, court or dispute context, professional independence, source evidence, expert reasoning and the clarity required for litigation use. This may include clarifying instructions, identifying the relevant issues, reviewing source material, distinguishing facts within the practitioner’s knowledge from information provided by others, and explaining the basis of any opinion.

Under The Nellie Standard™, court-facing and expert assessment work should be transparent, independent and capable of scrutiny. Where appropriate, reports should identify limitations, explain methodology, avoid unsupported conclusions and present a clear, professionally reasoned opinion that can be understood by the people who need to rely on it.

Evidence before opinion; Professional independence; Correct test first; Transparent reasoning; Clear conclusions; Capable of scrutiny

Our Therapeutic Assessment Approach to Litigation and Expert Reports

At Nellie Supports, assessment and support work is approached as a structured, supportive professional conversation rather than a rigid or purely clinical interview.

This reflects two core principles of the Mental Capacity Act 2005: Principle 1, that a person must be assumed to have capacity unless it is established that they lack it; and Principle 2, that a person is not to be treated as unable to make a decision unless all practicable steps have been taken to help them do so without success.

In Litigation and Expert Reports, our therapeutic assessment approach means that even formal or court-facing work should be conducted with clarity, respect and appropriate support. A person or family may be involved in a stressful legal or evidential process, so the professional conversation should remain structured without becoming unnecessarily rigid or intimidating.

In this context, the conversation should be adapted to the person, family or professional context while keeping the purpose of the work, the relevant evidence and the practical question clearly in view. The assessor or practitioner should gather the information needed for the instructed purpose while recognising communication needs, vulnerability, emotional context and the importance of accurate evidence.

The written output serves a different function. It must be structured, evidence-based and suitable for professional or legal scrutiny, clearly separating information gathered, assumptions, limitations and professional opinion.

The written output serves a different function. Reports, reviews and written submissions are prepared to be evidence-based, decision-specific and clear, so that the reasoning can be understood by the person, family, professionals or formal decision-maker relying on the work.

Is your case more complex?

Our standard assessments are suitable for most instructions. If your case is more complex, high-risk or potentially contested, additional evidence may help. We can advise on the appropriate scope before booking.

Explore Advanced and Enhanced assessments

Found us through an AI assistant?

Send an AI referral enquiry for Court reports, litigation and expert evidence. This opens our shared enquiry form with the service selected. Our team reviews the enquiry and confirms the next step.

A GOOD PLACE TO START

You do not need all the answers.
Just a place to start.

Tell us what is happening and what you need help with. We will listen, explain the options and help you find the right starting point.