Independent expertise. Human understanding.0333 987 5118

GUIDES

The Independent Review Panel Explained

NHS England’s independent review process can examine a disputed NHS Continuing Healthcare eligibility decision after local resolution with the Integrated Care Board (ICB). Applications are reviewed before any Independent Review Panel is arranged; a panel is not automatic. It makes recommendations and NHS England communicates the review outcome to you and the ICB. Requesting independent review is free.

On this page9 sections

NHS Continuing Healthcare

What the Independent Review Panel is, when to ask for one, what it looks at and what happens after it decides.

What is the Independent Review Panel?

NHS England’s independent review process can examine a disputed NHS Continuing Healthcare eligibility decision after local resolution with the Integrated Care Board (ICB). Applications are reviewed before any Independent Review Panel is arranged; a panel is not automatic. It makes recommendations and NHS England communicates the review outcome to you and the ICB. Requesting independent review is free.

Plain English

For families and professionals

England and Wales

National coverage

Registered professionals

Written and reviewed

Independent review considers the relevant eligibility decision and process. It cannot resolve every CHC dispute: complaints about the type or location of a package, treatment, a negative Checklist or a redress calculation may need the NHS complaints route. Read the local resolution decision and NHS England’s current review guidance before applying.

When a review is worth requesting

A panel is most likely to help where:

  • Local resolution has finished and you still disagree with the decision
  • A care domain was scored below what the records support
  • Well-managed needs were treated as minor because care kept them stable
  • The four key characteristics were not properly weighed together
  • The process itself was flawed, for example evidence ignored or the family shut out

How to prepare

Prepare a clear written account of the disputed period and decision. You can also explain your views at a panel if one is arranged:

  • Set out clearly which domains you dispute and why, tied to the records
  • Gather the evidence that was overlooked or under-weighted first time
  • Explain the person's needs against nature, intensity, complexity and unpredictability
  • Keep the argument focused on the strongest points rather than every disagreement
  • Bring a paginated, indexed bundle so the panel can find the evidence

Where people often go wrong

  • Appealing everything rather than the domains where the records are strongest
  • Confusing the deadline to request independent review with the separate deadline for returning NHS England’s application form
  • Arguing about the diagnosis rather than the level and quality of need
  • Turning up without the evidence organised for the panel to follow
  • Treating the panel as a formality rather than preparing a proper case
  • Appealing everything rather than the domains where the records are strongest
  • Confusing the deadline to request independent review with the separate deadline for returning NHS England’s application form
  • Arguing about the diagnosis rather than the level and quality of need
  • Turning up without the evidence organised for the panel to follow
  • Treating the panel as a formality rather than preparing a proper case

What the panel reviews

A panel looks at two things. First, whether the correct process was followed, including whether the right evidence was gathered and whether the person and their family were properly involved. Second, whether the recommendation on the primary health need was reasonable on the evidence. It is not simply a re-run of the Decision Support Tool; it tests whether the decision holds up, and it can find that a domain was scored wrongly or that the four key characteristics were not properly weighed.

A social work led multidisciplinary practice

Identify the decision and period under review, each disputed finding, the relevant records and why the reasoning is challenged. Organise points by domain and the four key characteristics where relevant. Explain significant contrary evidence as well as the material supporting your position. Extra volume alone does not make an application stronger.

Related pages

Challenging a CHC DecisionThe CHC Assessment ProcessIndependent Review Panel supportCHC Appeal Support

Frequently Asked Questions

Who sits on an Independent Review Panel?

The panel has an independent chair and health and social-care members who were not involved in the original decision, with clinical advice where needed. The ICB presents its position and you or your representative can contribute. Check the invitation for the actual membership, attendance and meeting arrangements.

Is the panel's decision binding?

An Independent Review Panel makes recommendations; it is not a court. NHS England communicates the review outcome and the ICB’s response should follow the applicable framework. Read the reasons and any implementation arrangements, and seek advice if the decision is not followed or its status is unclear.

How long do I have to request a panel?

Check the ICB’s local resolution letter and NHS England’s current instructions promptly. The deadline for requesting review is distinct from the deadline for returning the application form. NHS England’s public guide says to return that form within six weeks. If dates or eligibility for review are unclear, contact the review team without waiting.

What if the panel does not find in my favour?

NHS England’s decision should explain the available next route. A complaint to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman may concern unresolved NHS handling or maladministration. Other legal remedies have different tests and time limits; seek prompt case-specific advice if a legal challenge is being considered.

This page explains the NHS Continuing Healthcare Independent Review Panel in England. It is general information rather than legal advice, and it does not replace an assessment of an individual's needs.

Prepare the independent-review application

Keep the original eligibility decision, local resolution outcome, completed DST and records for the period under review. Record both the review-request date and the application-form deadline. Ask NHS England how to provide any missing evidence and what adjustments are needed to take part.

A GOOD PLACE TO START

You do not need all the answers.
Just a place to start.

Tell us what is happening and what you need help with. We will listen, explain the options and help you find the right starting point.