top of page
  • Writer's pictureBen Slater

How do you identify if someone needs a mental capacity assessment or if a mental capacity assessment is necessary?

To identify if someone needs a mental capacity assessment or if a mental capacity assessment is necessary, we first need to identify what a mental capacity assessment is. A Mental capacity assessment is a formal evaluation conducted to determine whether an individual can make a specific decision at a particular time. This assessment is crucial for ensuring that individuals who cannot make decisions for themselves due to an impairment of the mind or brain are provided with the necessary support and protection.

The assessment follows a legally defined process, typically outlined in frameworks such as the UK's Mental Capacity Act (2005). The purpose of the evaluation is to respect and uphold an individual's autonomy while ensuring they receive appropriate care and protection when they lack the capacity to make certain decisions.

elderly couple concerned about mental capacity

What are the reasons a mental capacity assessment could be necessary?

There are two different reasons a mental capacity assessment can be necessary: when you have concerns about a client's capacity to make a specific decision, for example, creating a lasting power of attorney or writing a will, and secondly, because you have concerns about their decision may be contested. 

The Golden Rule

The Golden Rule emerged from the case of Kenward v Adams 1975, during which Mr Justice Templeman said that where a testator (the person making the Will) is elderly or has been ill, an assessment of capacity should be undertaken. 

The "Golden Rule" in the context of making a will refers to a legal principle that emphasises the importance of taking certain precautions when preparing a will to avoid disputes or challenges after the testator's (the person making the will) death, particularly if the testator is elderly or suffers from any impairments that might affect their mental capacity.

The Golden Rule suggests that when a solicitor or will-writer is instructed to prepare a will for an elderly client or for someone whose mental capacity is doubted, it is prudent to have the testator's mental capacity assessed by a medical professional. Thus protecting both the client and the professional. 

While this applies specifically to testamentary mental capacity, the guidelines of where the person "is elderly or has been ill" is a good starting point for identifying red flags concerning capacity for any decision, especially those where there is concern it could be contested. 

How can you identify if someone's capacity may be impaired?

Significant Changes in Behavior or Mood: Sudden or gradual changes that are uncharacteristic of the person's usual behaviour or mood can indicate cognitive decline or mental health issues.

Difficulty Understanding or Communicating: Struggles to understand basic information, follow conversations, or express thoughts clearly might suggest impairments that affect decision-making capabilities.

Memory Issues: Noticeable difficulty in remembering recent events or retaining new information can impact one's ability to make informed decisions.

Poor Judgment and Decision-Making: Making decisions that are markedly poor or uncharacteristic, especially concerning financial matters or personal care, can be indicative of diminished capacity.

Disorientation: Confusion about time, place, or person, which might suggest cognitive impairments such as dementia or effects from medications or substances.

Decreased Understanding of Consequences: A lack of awareness or understanding about the consequences of decisions, especially in significant areas such as health care or financial management.

Social Withdrawal: Withdrawing from social interactions and activities can be linked to various conditions affecting mental capacity, including depression or dementia.

Unexplained Changes in Living Conditions: Deterioration in living conditions or personal hygiene might be due to an inability to make appropriate decisions related to daily living tasks.

Repeated Questions or Conversations: Frequently repeating the same questions or stories can indicate memory problems and difficulty processing new information.

Dependency and Influence: Increased reliance on others for decision-making or appearing to be unduly influenced or coerced by others can be a sign of vulnerability due to diminished capacity.

Why would a mental capacity assessment of someone who you know has sufficient capacity be needed?

Conducting a mental capacity assessment even when it is believed that someone has sufficient capacity can be critical, especially in situations where decisions are likely to be contested. This preemptive step is crucial for several reasons:

Evidence of Capacity: An assessment provides formal, documented evidence that the person had the necessary mental capacity at the time the decision was made. This documentation is invaluable in court or in disputes where the person’s capacity might be questioned by other parties.

Legal Protection: For decisions that have significant legal, financial, or health implications, ensuring that there is a record of the individual's capacity at the time the decision was made can protect the individual and other stakeholders from legal challenges. It also safeguards the individual's decisions against claims of undue influence or coercion.

Upholding Autonomy: A thorough assessment reaffirms the person’s ability to make independent decisions, thus upholding and respecting their autonomy. This is particularly important in a care context, where individuals’ choices might often be overridden or questioned due to biases about their age, disability, or mental health condition.

Mitigating Risks: If a decision is likely to be contentious (e.g., altering a will, making large financial gifts, or making unconventional medical choices), an assessment helps mitigate risks by ensuring that the decision-making process is sound and that the individual is truly acting of their own volition.

Professional Due Diligence: For professionals involved (such as lawyers, medical professionals, or financial advisors), conducting an assessment is part of due diligence. It ensures that they have adequately supported their client's decision-making process and can defend this support if required.

Peace of Mind: For the individual making the decision, knowing that their capacity has been formally assessed and confirmed can provide peace of mind, especially if they anticipate that their decisions might be questioned by family members or other interested parties.

Preventing Future Litigation: Early identification of any possible capacity issues through a thorough assessment can prevent more complex and costly litigation after the fact. This is particularly important in scenarios like estate planning or making advanced healthcare directives.

Overall, a mental capacity assessment in these situations acts as a proactive measure to ensure that decisions are respected and upheld, reducing the potential for disputes and ensuring that actions taken by or on behalf of the individual are legally sound and ethically justified.

A mental capacity assessment is a crucial tool designed to evaluate whether an individual can make specific decisions at particular times, particularly when their ability to do so might be impaired by mental or cognitive conditions. This formal evaluation is not only a protective measure under legal frameworks like the Mental Capacity Act (2005) but also a vital process to uphold and respect an individual's autonomy.

The necessity for such assessments arises under various circumstances. Primarily, it may be required when there is a concern about a person's ability to make significant decisions, such as those regarding their health, finances, or legal matters like wills. The Golden Rule specifically highlights the importance of assessing mental capacity in elderly or ill individuals preparing wills to prevent disputes and ensure that their decisions are respected and upheld posthumously.

Identifying the need for an assessment involves observing potential red flags such as changes in behaviour, memory issues, poor judgment, or difficulty in communication, which can indicate diminished capacity. These signs help professionals decide when to intervene proactively to assess capacity.

Moreover, conducting a mental capacity assessment, even for individuals presumed to have adequate capacity, is essential in situations where decisions may be contested. This preemptive approach provides documented evidence of capacity, offers legal protection, and ensures that the decision-making process is robust and defensible. It serves to mitigate risks, uphold autonomy, and provide peace of mind for all parties involved.

In conclusion, mental capacity assessments are not just about identifying incapacity but are fundamentally about protecting rights, providing appropriate support, and ensuring that decisions are made in an individual's best interest. They are a cornerstone in maintaining the dignity and independence of individuals facing challenges in decision-making, ensuring that their voices are heard and respected in critical life decisions.

if you need advice, support, or a mental capacity assessment, contact us at Nellie Supports

59 views0 comments


bottom of page